Handsome Hollow 5256 County Road 28 • Long Eddy • New York 12760


We'd love it if you would mention that you found Handsome Hollow on the Here Comes The Guide website.

Why You'll Love This Place

A Here Comes The Guide Wedding Venue Review
  • The vintage Amish barn is truly special. Built nearly 240 years ago, this historic treasure was a working dairy barn until it was painstakingly restored in 2014. It features a soaring ceiling, traditional post-and-beam construction, uniquely designed bathrooms and a fully equipped catering kitchen.
  • The grounds are beautiful. 93 acres of pristine Catskills wilderness—meadows, maple forests, creeks, and blueberry fields—are available for you and your guests to explore. Ceremonies may be held outdoors in a number of lovely spots, such as a romantic crumbling stone wall and an ancient apple orchard.
  • Your rental includes a complimentary 2-night stay in the charming 100-year-old farmhouse. This idyllic home has three bedrooms and sleeps up to six people, so you and your family or friends can settle in for the weekend. It’s stylishly decorated, and has a lovely “prep lounge” for day-of primping.


Only ONE remaining Spring 2025 weekend left: May 10, 2025. Book now and receive a discounted price of $14,000!

PRICES: What's this going to cost?

Rental Fee
  • $15,500–20,000/event
  • Rental fee varies depending on:
    • Day of week
    • Time of year
  • The rental fee includes a full weekend on the 93 acre secluded property, 2-night stay in the farmhouse, wooded ceremony surrounded by ferns, an extensive collection of vintage props, tables, chairs, and more.


Indoors Outdoors
Ceremony Seated 200 200
Cocktails, etc. Standing 200 200
Reception Seated 200 200
Meetings Total meeting capacity for this venue is 200.

Venue Details

Site Uses

  • Ceremony
  • Outdoor Ceremony
  • Wedding Receptions
  • Outdoor Reception
  • Rehearsal Dinner
  • Special Events / Parties
  • Business Functions / Meetings
  • On-Site Accommodations
  • Late Night
  • LGBTQ+ Friendly

Essential Info


$$ • $$$



A licensed catering company must serve food and alcoholic drinks for the day. The caterer will provide a full cooking and serving staff including at least one bartender if alcohol is being served.

Amplified Music


Wheelchair Access

Wheelchair accessible


Mid-May to mid-October.

Venue Type

Buildings & other settings available:

  • Barn
  • Historic / Landmark Building
  • Inn / Lodge
  • Patio / Deck / Terrace

Venue Views

Peep the views you’ll enjoy from this venue!

  • Forest / Woods
  • Hills
  • Landscaped Grounds
  • Meadow / Fields
  • Mountains


Wondering what CBA or BYO means?
Want more info on our editorial process?

Send an email to Handsome Hollow

Oh, no. How embarrassing!

Our website is overwhelmed.
Please click SEND EMAIL to try again.

We play nice. We promise never to share your info with anyone except Handsome Hollow.

We Play Nice

Wedding Venues  >  New York Wedding Venues  > Upstate Wedding Venues  > Catskills Wedding Venues