Handsome Hollow 5256 County Road 28 • Long Eddy • NY 12760


VISIT WEBSITE

We'd love it if you would mention that you found Handsome Hollow on the Here Comes The Guide website.



Why You'll Love This Place

A Here Comes The Guide Wedding Venue Review
  • The vintage Amish barn is truly special. Built nearly 240 years ago, this historic treasure was a working dairy barn until it was painstakingly restored in 2014. It features a soaring ceiling, traditional post-and-beam construction, uniquely designed bathrooms and a fully equipped catering kitchen.
  • The grounds are beautiful. 93 acres of pristine Catskills wilderness—meadows, maple forests, creeks, and blueberry fields—are available for you and your guests to explore. Ceremonies may be held outdoors in a number of lovely spots, such as a romantic crumbling stone wall and an ancient apple orchard.
  • Your rental includes a complimentary 2-night stay in the charming 100-year-old farmhouse. This idyllic home has three bedrooms and sleeps up to six people, so you and your family or friends can settle in for the weekend. It’s stylishly decorated, and has a lovely “prep lounge” for day-of primping.

Video

Video by Shutter and Sound.

Video by Elias Johnson.


DEALS: What discounts, special offers, or packages are available here?

Midweek single-day events start at $8,000! Contact the venue for more details and availability.


Limited 2026 dates are available!
Book your 2026 wedding and receive complimentary handmade farm tables for up to 150 guests. Please contact the venue for more details.

PRICES: What's this going to cost?

Rental Fee
  • $12,000/event and up
  • Rental fee varies depending on:
    • Day of week
    • Time of year
  • The rental fee includes:

    • Full access Friday noon–Sunday 2pm to the 93-acre property, encompassing meadows, creeks, and hiking trails
    • 2-night stay in the 3-bedroom farmhouse
    • Choice of ceremony site: wildflower field, stone wall ruin, or fern forest
    • Bluestone cocktail patio and restored 18th-century barn
    • Midnight curfew with no noise ordinance
    • Large bonfire with Adirondack chairs
    • Full commercial kitchen, professional sound system, and atmospheric lighting throughout
    • Banquet tables and vintage wood chairs
    • Venue support staff
    • Parking for up to 40 vehicles (shuttle service is recommended for guest safety & convenience)

    Add-on options include vintage tableware, farm tables, use of the space for a rehearsal dinner/farewell brunch, and more. 

Additional Info
  • Handsome Hollow's unique, vintage tableware is available to rent!

COUPLES ARE ASKING: We've got answers

What's included when we book Handsome Hollow, and what will we still need to pay for separately?

A weekend buyout at Handsome Hollow in Long Eddy includes a 2-night stay in the 3-bedroom farmhouse, the restored 4,200 sq ft barn, your choice of one of three ceremony sites, two bluestone cocktail patios, banquet tables and vintage wood chairs for 200, a full commercial kitchen, a sound system in the barn, a bonfire with Adirondack chairs and venue support staff. You'll pay separately for catering, vintage tableware or farm tables, event insurance, and an extra site fee and bathroom if you're over 150 guests.

Can we have both our ceremony and reception at Handsome Hollow, or will guests need to travel between them?

Yes, everything happens on the 93-acre property, so guests stay put. You pick one of three ceremony sites: a fern-lined clearing in the maple forest, an open wildflower field with mountain views, or the bluestone ruins of the original barn, a few seconds' walk from the reception barn. The barn also offers an indoor ceremony option, and the reception follows in the barn and on the bluestone patios.

If we already have vendors we love, can we bring them to Handsome Hollow or do we have to use yours?

Yes, you can bring vendors who aren't on Handsome Hollow's recommended list, though your caterer and planner need the venue's approval before you book them. Food and alcohol must be served by a licensed caterer, who brings a full cooking and serving staff plus at least one bartender if you're serving alcohol. Your caterer also handles setup, breakdown and cleanup, and every vendor has to follow the venue's policies.

What should we realistically expect to spend on a wedding at Handsome Hollow, and is there a minimum?

Weekend buyouts at Handsome Hollow in Long Eddy start at $12,000, and catering isn't included. Your guest count, vendors and style move the total most. The venue's own guide to other costs: catering $110–350 per person (food, bar and service), rentals $35–85 per person, florals $4,000–15,000, photography $5,000–12,000, a DJ $3,000–8,000, planning $2,500–12,000, transportation $2,500–5,000 and event insurance $250–350. Going over 150 guests adds a site fee and a required extra bathroom rental, and a rehearsal dinner or goodbye brunch for more than 20 guests carries its own site fee. A 25% deposit holds your date.

How long do we get at Handsome Hollow, and when does the music have to stop?

Handsome Hollow is a weekend rental, with access from Friday at noon through Sunday at 2pm. There's no noise ordinance, and the curfew is 12am for guests who aren't staying on site. The barn has a professional sound system, and amplified music is allowed indoors and outdoors, so your reception can go right up to midnight.

Where would our out-of-town guests stay near Handsome Hollow, and can you help with a room block?

Your rental at Handsome Hollow includes a 2-night stay in the 3-bedroom farmhouse, which sleeps up to six and doubles as your getting-ready space, so you and your closest people can wake up on site. Everyone else has plenty of options within 5–30 minutes, including hotels, motels, cabins, inns, Airbnbs and two large resorts. Parking is limited to 40 cars a short walk from the barn, so the venue recommends hiring a bus service to shuttle guests between their lodging and the property.

What makes Handsome Hollow different from the other venues near it?

Handsome Hollow is a true weekend barn wedding: you get the property from Friday noon to Sunday 2pm, plus two nights in the 3-bedroom farmhouse. The barn itself is about 240 years old, a working dairy barn moved and rebuilt on 93 acres of Catskills meadows, maple forest and creeks. You choose your own vendors, including your caterer, and the party can run to midnight with no noise ordinance. Three ceremony sites, a bonfire with Adirondack chairs and hiking trails mean your guests can explore the whole weekend.

GUEST COUNT: How many people can we have here? What’s the max capacity?

Indoors Outdoors
Ceremony Seated 200 200
Cocktails, etc. Standing 200 200
Reception Seated 200 200
Meetings Total meeting capacity for this venue is 200.

Venue Info & FAQs

OPTIONS: What kinds of events can we have here?

  • Outdoor Ceremony
  • Ceremony
  • Wedding Receptions
  • Outdoor Reception
  • LGBTQ+ Friendly
  • Small Wedding
  • Rehearsal Dinner
  • Special Events / Parties
  • Business Functions / Meetings
  • On-Site Accommodations
  • Late Night

POLICIES: What are the food, alcohol, music, and other rules here?

Price

$ • $$ • $$$

Catering

BYO

A licensed catering company must serve food and alcoholic drinks for the day. The caterer will provide a full cooking and serving staff including at least one bartender if alcohol is being served.


Alcohol

BYO



Amplified Music

Indoors
Outdoors

Wheelchair Access

Wheelchair accessible

Availability

Mid-May to mid-October.

STYLE: What’s the style and overall vibe of this venue?

Buildings & other settings available:

  • Barn
  • Historic / Landmark Building
  • Inn / Lodge
  • Patio / Deck / Terrace

VIEWS: What kind of views does this place have?

Peep the views you’ll enjoy from this venue!

  • Forest / Woods
  • Hills
  • Landscaped Grounds
  • Meadow / Fields
  • Mountains

Wondering what CBA or BYO means?
Want more info on our editorial process?

Handsome Hollow

Send an email to Handsome Hollow

We Play Nice

We play nice. We promise never to share your info with anyone except Handsome Hollow.

Your email is on its way!

Keep AN EYE ON YOUR INBOX
FOR A RESPONSE FROM
Handsome Hollow

*Sending your email through the Here Comes The Guide website lets this venue know we sent you! Thank you for your support!

Wedding Venues  >  New York Wedding Venues  > Upstate Wedding Venues  > Catskills Wedding Venues